|
My Children |
(Written
by Investigative journalist Jack London for Noseweek, March 2007. All writing
between brackets is mine)
Dianne Lang, known
with affection as “Mamma Dee” in the townships around a small Karoo town for
her work with abandoned and “at risk” children, has fled the country, following
a blitzkrieg of raids by the Scorpions investigating the alleged
misappropriation of more than R1m of donor funds from her award-winning
project. Before she took off for London
on 6 February, Dianne, who has not been charged, claimed that the elite
crime-busting unit was set on her by a police inspector in the Great Karoo town
of Middelburg – after she rejected him as a lover.
Noseweek has
also unearthed disquieting evidence that officers from the Scorpions were
involved in an unauthorised investigation at 50-year-old Dianne for a full year
before the probe was officially sanctioned.
During this time, speculation about her pending arrest swirled around
Middelburg, causing her eventually to flee the town, her reputation in tatters.
“I
have not misappropriated funds nor have I taken money from the children”, she
says now. “But my reputation is gone: I
am already considered a criminal.”
On
5 (6)December last year, (2006) in “Operation Dynamite”, Scorpions teams from
Eastern Cape headquarters in East London swooped on eight premises in
Middelburg and Port Elizabeth, removing computers and financial records of her
SA Care Trust, which operates as the Dianne Lang Foundation. The search and seizure warrants state that
there is reasonable suspicion that theft and/or fraud, as well as
money-laundering and/or racketeering in contravention of the Organized Crime
Act, has been committed against SA Care Trust from the beginning of 2003.
The
Scorpions’ operational head in Pretoria, deputy director David Demerell, tells Noseweek that he signed the
authorisation for a preliminary investigation, called a Section 28 (13), in
July or August last year. However, a
year previously – in August 2005 – Dianne was tipped off that she was being
secretly investigated by the unit.
In
the apartheid years Dianne Lang was a card-carrying member of the ANC and a
Black Sash activist. More lately she was
a counselling psychologist in Port Elizabeth until she decided to launch her
own fight against the Aids pandemic, with a support centre for HIV positive
residents of the townships clustered around Middelburg. The town (population 44 000) lies in the
Sneeuberg mountain range in the Great Karoo, surrounded by sheep and game
farms. “Everyone knows everyone or is related to them,” says a local.
With
a R15 000 donation from Vodacom, Dianne bought a tumbledown house in the
middle of town for a support centre. One
night in the middle of winter she found three children on her doorstep, two
10-year-olds who had been gang-raped and a desperately ill three-year-old. When she took them to the local offices of
the department of social development she was told: “These are street children; put them back on
the street”.
A
doctor in town told her the children would all die soon of Aids. “I thought, well, I’ll keep them till they
die. At least I’ll nurse them and they
won’t die hungry, cold and alone”.
Thus
Dianne’s epiphany became the district’s needy children – HIV positive or
not. She sold her house in Port
Elizabeth’s Blue Horizon Bay and after paying off the bond used the balance for
start-up funds. Today 35 children live
at Care House, looked after by a staff of seven, plus volunteers from America
and the UK.
However,
the arrival of black children at the project’s five houses in the mainly-white
centre of town, plus her crusading style, made waves. The wife of a prominent resident came to her
door and told her: “I’ve just come to warn you that if you don’t get these
kaffirs out of town, we’re going to burn your houses down”.
Relations
with the local office of the Department of Social Development have never been
smooth, either. “They are totally
incompetent and there is no service delivery from them,” says Dianne. “I’ve been a pain in their side”.
It
seems that things were looking up when police Inspector Louis Jenner arrived on
the scene. Jenner and his “van partner”,
Inspector Wollie Meyer, are both area representatives of the SA Police Union,
and figures to be reckoned with in this small community. Jenner became chairperson of Care House’s
house committee, and threw himself enthusiastically into his charitable duties.
Running
Care House, says Dianne, costs about R70 000 to R80 000 per
month. International donors have rallied
to the cause, the largest being the UK’s Grace Foundation, with an on-going
contribution of £2500 (presently around R35 000 per month). Every six months Dianne would set off for the
UK, to raise more ever-needed funds through lecture tours. One trip raised a record R100 000.
In
2005 her work with needy children was recognised when she won the Clarins Most
Dynamisante Woman of the Year Award. She
handed the R150 000 prize money over for the children. But 2005 also brought turmoil in Middelburg
as her relationship with Inspector Louis Jenner soured. On April 5 there was a stormy visit by Jenner
to her house, and the following day Dianne appealed for help in a “confidential
report” to Middelburg’s acting police commander, Captain Flip Meiring.
After
Jenner became chairperson of her house committee, wrote Dianne, he became very
involved with Care House. “At first I
thought this was because he was chairperson, but later it became obvious that
this was an excuse to spend time in my company”. “I very soon realised that I was not dealing
with a normal case of love, but one of obsession. He said he was in love with me and could not
help it”. When she remonstrated, Jenner would
”get mad and slam the door”.
During
one of these outbursts Dianne told her suitor that she no longer wanted him in
her house and suggested that he resign from the house committee. “He told me I was a dishonest and despicable
person and that I would pay for what I had done to him”.
She
had already fallen out with Jenner’s “van partner” and fellow SA Police Union
representative colleague, Inspector Wollie Meyer. She had trained his brother Neil Meyer as a
home-based care worker, but after a string of verbal and written warnings
started in February 2005 (falsifying attendance record, physically punishing
children, dereliction of duty, gross insubordination, etc.), Neil Meyer was
dismissed after a disciplinary hearing on 12 September.
Between
that July and September there were three mysterious burglaries in Middelburg –
one at Dianne’s house and two at the Care House office. At the office, computers were taken, as well
as trust files. In the last break-in, on
25 September, messages were scrawled on the wall: “watch out bitch”, “easy to
kill you bitch” and so on. The culprits
were never found. The day after the 17
September second break-in, Neil Meyer’s brother, InspectorWollie Meyer, was
saying: “the computers are already in East London (the Scorpions’ regional HQ)
and the shit’s going to hit the fan in Middelburg”.
Dianne
first became aware of the Scorpions’ covert – and, we now discover,
unauthorised – operation during August 2005, when she was called to the office
of the headmaster of Middelburg’s VDM school, Edgar Williams. In an affidavit, Dianne says the headmaster
“informed me that Inspector TC (Wollie) Meyer has been to see him to tell him
that I was under investigation by the Scorpions”. Rumours of Dianne’s imminent arrest swept
through town. She stuck it out for a
year until last August – the time the preliminary investigation was finally
authorised – when she returned to Port Elizabeth, leaving the children of Care
House under the collective wing of manager Diana Jagers and the rest of the
team.
It
was also last August that Dianne discovered who had put the Scorpions onto
her. On 22 August she attended a meeting
with Advocate Dale Robinson of the National Prosecuting Authority in
Grahamstown, to discuss the status of a case she had opened against Inspector
Louis Jenner for assault and crimen injuria.
With her was a private detective, former police brigadier Charlie Kemp whom
Dianne had hired to help her. Says
Kemp: “Jenner had made a statement about
the allegations made against him by Dianne.
Advocate Robinson read the statement to us and in it Jenner said he had
reported her to the Scorpions for embezzling funds”.
Will
Manual is the Scorpions’ East London-based investigating officer in Dianne’s
case. Manual declines to discuss the
investigation and will only confirm: “It’s
ongoing”.
In
Middleburg, Inspector Jenner, married and father of three, is reluctant to talk
about Dianne Lang, other than to confirm that he fell out with her. “She decided she wants to operate the Care
House on her own,” he says. Jenner
denies it was he who made the complaint against Dianne to the Scorpions. “No. Who says so? Who gave you that
information?,” he demands. “From your
statement,” we reply. “Where did you get
that information from?”
Why
are the Scorpions involved in this case at all, when the amount allegedly
involved is apparently not much more than R1m?
The unit’s guidelines say that fraud and economic offences should
generally exceed R10m before they get involved.
Deputy director David Demerell explains that intake criteria may be
relaxed when it comes to factors like international donor money and the poorest
of the poor. A fortnight before last
December’s raids Demerell authorised the probe into Dianne to be upgraded to
full Section 28 (1) status.
So
what evidence has Will Manual and his colleagues at the Scorpions dug up on
Dianne Lang? A bunch of payments
totalling more than R1m from the bank account of SA Care Trust into her
personal account, we can reveal. Dianne
doesn’t deny it – and says there’s a simple explanation. “I borrowed money on my overdraft and lent
the foundation money. Then when
donations come in, I paid myself back.”
The
trust’s unaudited accounts for the year ending 28 February 2005 – prepared by
the Port Elizabeth accountancy firm of Buckingham and Associates – show that
Dianne received a total salary that year of R35 000 (a frugal R2916 per
month). They also record that she was
owed R418 778 for long-term loans.
Noseweek has established
that in July 2005, after a welcome R75 000 donation from “PNP Golf Day”,
the trust’s bank balance stood at R288 925. This, however, was depleted by a whopping
R200 000 paid to Dianne in two amounts of R100 000 – on 26 July and
13 September – leaving the trust, after other minor disbursements, with just
R78 966,78. (These payments were for personal loans to the trust).
Around
that time Dianne’s managing director’s salary was increased to R16 000 per
month – the amount she’s still drawing to this day. SA Care Trust’s trustee and bookkeeper, Port
Elizabeth businessman Stuart Irvine, says: “Since 2003 the trust has received
in excess of R1m from Dianne in loans that she raised through her overdraft and
house loan. These have been repaid to
her when we have funds. She’s still owed
more that R200 000.
At
Buckingham & Associates, the Scorpions removed financial records and a
computer as the firm’s Christine Hickman was finishing the trust’s 2006
accounts. “I gave them a good dressing
down,” says Hickman. “They think Dianne’s
embezzling funds, which is absolutely ridiculous”.
Vodacom
and a Netherlands charity, Stichting Kinderpostzegels, have both withdrawn
their support of SA Care Trust. But the
Grace Foundation’s £2500 per month is still trundling in. And last November, a month before the raids,
Dianne’s old enemy, the Department of Social Development, came up with a one-off subsidy payment of R182 000. (By this time Dianne was looking after 76
children)
SA
Care Trust’s bank balance is now down to R70 000 – barely enough to get
through last month. “I’ve got to raise
money, otherwise we’re going to close down,” says Dianne from the UK. She plans to stay in London for at least a
year. “I feel despair: can I carry on
any longer? I feel anger: that the
persons who have caused all this – and I know who they are – can get away with
it. I feel confusion: I know I was doing
the right thing, saving the children, making a difference in their lives. So why is it all so difficult?”
Down
in Middleburg, plumber Hough Theron, who lives next door to Care House in Smid
Street and takes its children fishing at nearby Grassridge dam, has a view on
that. “If Dianne hadn’t come in and made
such a dramatic impact, perhaps people would have accepted her. Her big mistake was to make an impact and
they didn’t like that. They said: “For 10, 20, 30 years we’ve been doing it
this way, why should we change?” “Louis
Jenner got absolutely carried away with her, but Dianne wasn’t interested at
all”.
(On
17th December 2008, the Scorpions returned everything they had seized during
their raid expect one computer and another computer was returned in pieces. Together with the trust’s returned materials
were the materials of two other companies which had obviously been under
investigation. One box of documents had
gone mission. A letter from the
Scorpions admits to damaging the computers and makes a claim that when funds
were available, the computers would be returned/replaced. They would also look for the missing box of
documents. This never happened. I
believe that the severe stress I endured played a large part in my subsequent
diagnosis of leukemia. I have never been
charged and I have never been notified of the outcome of the
investigation. However, the Scorpions inadvertently
left the forensic audit amongst the returned documentation. Over a five year period there was R11.00 unaccounted for. This could have been for anything from buy
stamps and not recording it or giving children pocket money or money that they
needed for school. How much it cost the
state to chase after me boggles the mind, but sadder still was the fate of the
children. They had lost their Mamma D
and I had lost my children. The home
closed in 2010, leaving more than R400 000 in my loan account, when all
the children were either returned to their parents, to foster parents or to the
streets. While many children have died
during this time, many are now adults and we are still in contact. A Christian group took over 7 foster
children. Will Manual is a private
investigator, Jenner and Meyer have been promoted and Meiring has left the
police force. I was very traumatised by
what had happened and this article is a very small part of what went down. Amnesty International and the Helen Bamber
Foundation for victims of political torture helped me to understand what had
happened to me. They also gave me
insight into why the Scorpions behaved in the manner that they did. It is all designed to put the “suspect” under
extreme mental and emotional pressure. I
had not only lost all my money, but I had lost my sense of security and the
foundation on which I had always lived.
The Helen Bamber Foundation gave
me back to me. I have wanted to write
the sequel to Saving Mandela’s Children, but the hurt is still fresh and I am
not ready to go through the documentation to write another book of this nature
just yet.)